Blogs,  Jeshua

Twice a Week

200 - The Pharisee and the Tax Collector

“God, I thank you that I am not like other people… I fast twice a week.”

That’s how the prayer of the Pharisee begins in Jesus’ parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector. That parable (Lk 18:9-14) is the regularly appointed Gospel for Ash Wednesday, the first day of the season of Lent.

Now, to be fair to the Pharisees, this story isn’t a report. Luke tells us that it is a parable, an illustration used to teach a spiritual truth. So we might rightly wonder, “Did some or all of the Pharisees actually fast twice a week? And if so, why?”

There were two kinds of fasts in Jesus’ day – a public fast and a private fast. The public fast was mandatory for everyone. It took place on the Day of Atonement and at times of national crises, such as drought, crop failure, epidemics, or war. It was somewhat akin to the modern national day of prayer or flying the flag at half-mast.

The Day of Atonement fast was a one-day fast. In the case of drought, a full fasting observance lasted 13 days. Monday and Thursday were always the fasting days, so that the entire fast lasted about six and half weeks. Monday and Thursday were chosen because they had no contact with the Sabbath day and because they were far enough apart to prevent the fast from making demands on a person’s health that were too strenuous.

People often observed the fast by sitting in prayer. In fact, one common expression for fasting was “sitting in a fast.”

The private fast was a voluntary fast for individuals. It used to be an occasional event (see e.g. 2Sa 12:16; Dan 9:3), but by the final two centuries BC it had become a regular practice, at least in some Jewish circles. The individual could fast whenever he chose, except for the Sabbath day, festival days, or other national days of joy. But by Jesus’ day people usually undertook a private fast on the same days designated for the public fast – Monday and Thursday.

The private fast came to be so highly regarded in the synagogues as an expression of devotion to God that two special, regular practices arose. First, there were certain “men of standing.” These men had to represent the entire Jewish people either at the daily morning burnt offering at the temple, or by assembling at their local synagogue for joint Scripture reading and prayer. They served one week at a time. When it was their turn to serve, they fasted and prayed from Monday through Thursday – on Monday for the safety of those traveling by sea, on Tuesday for the safety of those traveling by desert, on Wednesday that the children might not be inflicted with angina, and on Thursday for the safety of the pregnant and nursing.
However, web sites where email addresses are posted have struck back with threats of legal look these up samples viagra action against anyone that copies addresses and uses them for the purpose of building mailing lists or sending marketing offers. Drugs: Both illegal and prescribed drugs can impact cheapest sildenafil 100mg sperm. cheap generic tadalafil Diabetics possess a likelihood of burning off sensory operate to the anxious feelings of your legs, a common condition named peripheral neuropathy. Below is a short description on available forms that relieve the condition- Kamagra tablets: -Unlike other ED drugs, you can nowadays even price of cialis. levitra: How Does it Work? The working of purchase levitra is quite similar to downtownsault.org, this drug has huge and unnecessary risk when brought from offshore websites.
Secondly, some Jews were especially zealous for the law and wanted to go above and beyond the service rendered by the men of standing. They regularly fasted twice a week, every Monday and Thursday. Some who did this were even allowed to continue their fast if one of the national days of joy fell on a Monday or Thursday, if they took their fasting vow before these national days of joy were publicized. Such regular fasts could last for a year or even longer. The Pharisees, who took special pride in their standing before God and the people, would have valued such fasting, even if each one of them did not undertake it himself.

Why would someone undertake such a fast? Many Jewish scholars considered fasting to have the power to atone for sin. Men who undertook such regular fasting twice a week were hoping to turn away God’s wrath and thus guard the Jewish people from any national tragedy. According to Jewish tradition, one rabbi named Zadok, who lived around 50 AD, “sat in fast [fasted every Monday and Thursday] for forty years in order that Jerusalem might not be destroyed.”

The Pharisee Jesus put into his parable doubtless belongs in this second category. He carried the welfare of the Israelites on his heart as he fasted and prayed week after week. The people would have looked up to him as extraordinarily devout and many would have regarded him with gratitude. After all, by his fasting he was supposedly earning God’s mercy and atoning for their sins. If things went well for the Jews and their families, it was partially due to men such as he, so they thought.

What a shock it must have been, then, when Jesus told his audience that the tax collector, “rather than [the Pharisee], went home justified before God”!

Fasting in itself was not sinful. David and Daniel fasted. John the Baptist’s disciples fasted (Mt 9:14). The early Christians fasted (Ac 13:1-3). Martin Luther wrote in his Small Catechism that “fasting and other outward preparations may serve a good purpose” in preparing to receive the Lord’s Supper. Perhaps one of the reasons this Gospel was appointed for Ash Wednesday is that many devout Christians today still fast during the season of Lent.

But if we treat fasting as a work of righteousness in which we can trust (Lk 18:9), especially when God has not commanded us to fast; if we think that we can atone for our own sins or the sins of others by fasting; if we fast to show off instead of in humility (Lk 18:14); then our fasting is damnable, because it is based on a lie.

Jesus has already turned away God’s wrath over our sin once and for all (Ro 5:9-11). No further atonement needs to be made. This Lent, let us humble ourselves before God, not in order to receive anything from him. Sinners such as we cannot earn anything from him. But let us humble ourselves precisely because in the life and death of Christ God has already blessed us with everything (Eph 1:3).

For further reading: Isaiah 58; Matthew 6:16-18; Luke 18 and Fasting

Hello and welcome! I’m Pastor Nathan Biebert. I currently serve as a pastor in the South of the U.S.A. When my pastoral duties aren't occupying my time, you will often find me translating German or Latin, bicycling, hiking, fly fishing, or reading a good book alongside my wife. May God bless you during your time here at Bread for Beggars and as you carry out your God-given vocation in the world!

3 Comments

  • Mark Parsons

    Thank you for the informative post. Does fasting have any value in the Christian life today? If so what are some practical ways that one could avoid turning it into a work of self-rightousness and actually benefit from it spiritually?

    • Pastor Nathaniel Biebert

      I followed up on your question by talking at length with the third person I mentioned in my first reply. Since his first two-week fast in 2011, he has undertaken two additional fasts. Last year he fasted during the entire season of Lent (all 46 days), drinking nothing but raw milk. This year he is also fasting during the entire season of Lent, but he is not restricting the liquids he can drink.

      He said, in his view, fasting has three spiritual benefits, but he conceded that he has really only enjoyed the first of these benefits:

      1. Even though your body adjusts to the fast after the first few days (and all the more quickly if it isn’t the first time you’ve fasted), the desire for food is always there. It never goes away. So by not satisfying that desire, even though food a-plenty is always available, it serves as an awesome spiritual reminder of what our Savior went through from the moment he was conceived to the moment he rose from the dead. He could easily have made use of his divine power, attributes, etc. at his disposal, but he knew that was not his Father’s will, nor the path to our salvation. (He didn’t have the desire to make use of what he had given up in the same way we desire food when fasting, but there is a certain parallel.) More particularly, it gives one some idea of what Jesus went through in the wilderness during his 40-day fast early in his ministry, when he was being tempted by the devil.

      2. What one doesn’t spend on food, one can spend on food for the poor and needy.

      3. What time one doesn’t spend on eating, one can spend in prayer and meditation.

      This acquaintance said he couldn’t benefit from #2 and #3, because he still had a family to provide for (so the money he would have saved was proportionately less than if he only had to provide for himself), and he still considered meals as vital time to spend with his family, even if he himself wasn’t eating.

      Incidentally, he also mentioned that it had physical health benefits as well. He ran in a local race during his fast last year, and posted his best time ever.

      One must of course undertake such endeavors with caution and wisdom, and take great care not to look down on others or think that merit is being gained with God, but in this man’s case, it seems that fasting has and will continue to serve a good gospel-centered purpose.

  • Pastor Nathaniel Biebert

    To your first question, I can only say Yes, but I can’t say it from experience, and I can’t say it definitely for every single Christian. Jesus commended the practice of fasting; he just didn’t command it (Matthew 6:16-18). And if Jesus commended it, it must have some value for at least some Christians.

    I only know of three Christians firsthand who have practiced fasting. The first two didn’t give many details. One said it gave him a sharper focus and clarity of thought. The other said it just distracted him.

    The third said he fasted for two weeks (not just on Monday and Thursday, but every day), drinking nothing but raw milk. Before he fasted, he assumed that it would keep him from fulfilling his vocation to his normal standards. And once he tried it, he did say that he was more tired than usual for the first couple days. But after that, he got used to it and worked his normal days. He even played “as well as ever” in a church softball game and worked all day in his garden under a blazing sun without ill effect. He was thinking about trying it for an entire month the next time. Unfortunately, this man didn’t go into any detail about any spiritual value this fast did or did not have for him.

    Looking at the practice simply from a psychological standpoint, I think that, in a culture where we not only get almost every food we want, and not only get it instantly, but also get it and consume it in large quantities, fasting could serve a good, spiritual purpose, especially during Lent, in at least two ways: 1. By reminding us that we cannot always have everything we want; in fact, Jesus tells us that those who follow him must be ever ready to lose their life for him and for the gospel (Mark 8:35). 2. By reminding us of the humiliation Jesus endured for our sake. By “humiliation,” I don’t just mean the mockery and physical abuse he endured, but his entire human life up to his resurrection during which he did not make full or frequent use of the power and authority at his disposal. Jesus fasted not from food, but from his divinity, so to speak, for us.

    And that kind of answers your second question too. Keep your thoughts on Christ, and his work for you. The most practical way would be to read the Bible every day, because the Bible will not let you get away with thoughts of work-righteousness unless you are completely ignoring it.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.